What to do when a water heater stops working in Kerrville

A quiet morning in Kerrville turns long fast when the shower runs cold. A water heater failure shows up without warning, and it interrupts a day of school drop-offs, ranch chores, or shifts at the hospital. The good news: most water heater problems follow a few common patterns. With a structured check and local know-how, homeowners can often pinpoint the issue and decide whether a repair or replacement makes more sense. For anyone who wants fast, reliable help from a Kerrville plumber, this walkthrough also sets the stage for a clean service visit that solves the problem on the first trip.

This article lays out what to check safely, what to leave to a pro, and how a local team approaches water heater repair across Kerrville neighborhoods like Keystone, Riverhill, Starkey, and Comanche Trace. It also explains why certain symptoms show up the way they do. The goal is clear information that supports a quick, confident call for service with a trusted plumber near me.
First steps: safety and quick checks
A failing water heater can create hazards. Gas leaks, electrical shorts, and scalding temperatures are the big three. Start with safety. If there is the smell of gas, leave the house and call the gas company first. For electric heaters, power off the breaker before removing any panels. If water is actively leaking, shut off the cold-water inlet on top of the tank and the gas or electrical supply.

In many Kerrville homes, the water heater sits in a garage or utility closet with limited airflow. Make sure the area is clear of stored items. Gas units need air for combustion. A broom handle that fell against the intake can snuff the burner and lead to repeated shutdowns.

Now, look for three fast indicators: the status light or error code on the control module, the temperature setting on the thermostat, and whether hot water returns briefly after a reset. Those clues save time during a call with Kerrville plumbers and often hint at the fix.
No hot water at all: electric units
Electric models rely on two heating elements and thermostats, one at the top and one at the bottom. In many service calls around Kerrville, a tripped high-limit switch is the simplest cause. With power off at the breaker, remove the upper access panel, peel back the insulation, and press the red reset button. If hot water returns but trips again within a day, that points to a thermostat sticking closed or an element shorting to ground.

A burned-out upper element leaves a tank ice cold. A failed lower element leaves short bursts of hot water followed by long cold stretches. A tech confirms this with a multimeter and a continuity test. Most elements in the area are 4500-watt, but some older homes run 3500-watt elements on smaller breakers. Replacing with the wrong wattage can cause nuisance trips.

A note from the field: Kerrville’s water is moderately hard. Scale forms on elements faster in homes near older galvanized lines or where the softener has been off for a while. Scale insulates the element and causes slow heat and premature failure. If elements burn out more than once in two years, sediment or scale is likely the root problem.
No hot water: gas units
For gas water heaters, the basics are fuel, ignition, and venting. Look at the pilot status or electronic ignition indicator. Many newer models use a spark igniter rather than a standing pilot. If the pilot will not stay lit, common causes include a clogged pilot orifice, a weak thermocouple, a failed thermopile, or a flame sensor covered in soot. Homes that back onto ranch roads or lots with dusty driveways see more of this. Dust collects in the burner chamber and changes the flame pattern. A Kerrville plumber will clean the burner assembly and check millivolt readings to confirm sparking and flame signal.

If the pilot lights but goes out when the gas control is released, the thermocouple likely failed. If the pilot lights and stays but the main burner never engages, the gas control valve may be faulty. For sealed combustion units with sidewall vents, check outside for wasp nests or grass clippings blocking the intake. Blocked intake stifles the flame and triggers safety shutdown. A tech will also check draft with a match test at the draft hood on atmospheric units. Reversed draft points to a vent blockage, wind effect, or negative pressure in tight garages.
Not enough hot water: recovery and usage mismatch
A common winter complaint is showers going lukewarm by the second person. Sometimes the tank is undersized for a family that has grown. A 40-gallon gas unit with a standard recovery rate may not keep up with back-to-back teenage showers and a dishwasher cycle. Electric recovery is slower than gas. If the water heater is older than 10 years and undersized, upgrading to a 50-gallon high-recovery gas model or a hybrid heat pump water heater can solve the daily shortfall while lowering operating cost.

When capacity should be adequate but recovery still lags, look for sediment. In Kerrville, sediment builds in tanks that have not been flushed. Two signs stand out: a rumbling or popping noise when the burner runs, and noticeable temperature drop mid-shower. Sediment traps heat at the bottom of the tank and reduces effective capacity. A flush can help if the tank is not yet heavily compacted. Once sediment has hardened like concrete, aggressive flushing risks leaks. In that situation, replacement is the smart move.
Water is too hot or not hot enough
A thermostat set too high is an obvious culprit. It happens after moves or during rental turnovers. For safety, most manufacturers recommend 120 degrees Fahrenheit. That is hot enough for hygiene and dishes, and it reduces scald risk. If water feels cooler at taps while the thermostat reads the same, one likely cause is a failed mixing valve at the tank outlet. Another is a broken dip tube. A dip tube routes incoming cold water to the bottom of the tank. When it splits, cold water mixes at the top and reaches fixtures before fully heating. Replacement is simple but requires the right tube length and material for the model.

An odd case seen in several Kerrville homes: whole-house recirculation pumps running continuously without a functioning check valve. This back-circulation pulls hot water from the tank and mixes it with cold water lines, leading to lukewarm taps. A plumber checks for this by closing the recirculation line temporarily. If temperatures stabilize, the fix involves a check valve or pump timer.
Discolored or smelly hot water
Brown or rust-colored water from hot taps points to corrosion, often from a failing anode rod or tank rust. If the discoloration clears after running cold taps but returns with hot water, the tank is the source. An anode rod swap can extend tank life if the tank shell is intact. If rust appears along with dampness around the base, the tank wall may be compromised. At that point, replacement is the safest path.

A rotten egg odor is usually hydrogen sulfide. It forms when sulfate-reducing bacteria react with the magnesium anode rod. This odor is more common in homes with wells outside city service, but it can occur on municipal water as well. A plumber can replace the anode with an aluminum-zinc rod and sanitize the tank. Adding a mixing valve allows maintaining 140 degrees at the tank and blending down at the fixtures, which helps suppress bacteria while keeping tap water safe.
Leaks: from minor to tank failure
A leak at the temperature and pressure relief valve often signals thermal expansion, debris under the valve seat, or a stuck thermostat. If the valve weeps occasionally after long heating cycles, an expansion tank may be missing or water pressure is high. Many Kerrville homes run 70 to Gottfried Plumbing llc plumbers Kerrville TX https://maps.app.goo.gl/NkSdBnnSgYtJdHwR7 90 psi without a pressure-reducing valve. That is above ideal. High pressure shortens appliance life and triggers relief valve discharge. A gauge on a laundry tap gives a quick read. A pressure-reducing valve and expansion tank stabilize both water heater and fixture performance.

Water around the base demands quick attention. If it is a slow drip from the drain valve, the insert can be replaced. If water seeps from the seam or from under the insulation, the tank wall has failed. Tanks rarely recover from internal leaks. Shut off water at the inlet valve, turn off fuel or power, and schedule replacement. For homeowners with pans piped to the exterior, a small discharge to the driveway can go unnoticed for weeks. A periodic glance at the pan helps catch problems before they grow.
Why water heaters fail sooner in some Kerrville homes
Local conditions matter. Hard water, high pressure, and location heat load all strain tanks. Garages in summer can exceed 100 degrees. Electric units in hot garages have higher standby loss, and gas units in dusty garages see more burner fouling. In older homes, galvanic corrosion from mixed metals at dielectric unions can damage nipples at the tank top. A Kerrville plumber who works daily in the area can spot these patterns fast.

Most standard tank water heaters last 8 to 12 years. Regular anode checks every two to three years can add time. Flushing sediment yearly helps where water hardness is moderate. If a unit has passed 12 years and repairs begin to stack up, replacement gives better value than chasing parts.
Tank or tankless: choosing the right fix
If the existing tank is leaking or undersized, it may be the right time to consider tankless. Tankless gas units free up floor space and supply continuous hot water. They also need proper gas capacity and venting. Many older Kerrville homes have 1/2-inch gas lines that cannot feed a high-BTU tankless without upgrades. That adds cost. A straightforward 50-gallon tank swap may be the smarter choice if the existing gas line and vent are marginal.

A hybrid heat pump water heater is an option in insulated garages or utility rooms with enough air volume. It uses ambient air to heat water and can cut electric costs substantially. It also cools and dehumidifies the space around it. In a tight closet, it may not perform well without ducting. An experienced team will measure clearances, power availability, and drainage for condensate before recommending this route.
What homeowners can safely check before calling
A short checklist helps isolate the issue and speeds service. Use this only if it can be done safely and without forcing stuck parts.
Look at the status light or code on the gas control or electric control panel, and note it for the tech. Confirm the breaker is on for electric units and reset the high-limit button behind the upper panel once. Check the thermostat setting and set it to 120 degrees if higher or much lower. Inspect for obvious leaks, especially at the drain valve, T&P valve, and supply connections. Make sure the gas shutoff valve is in line with the pipe and that the intake and vent are clear outside.
If anything smells like gas, skip the checklist and call the gas utility. If water is pooling fast, turn off the cold-water inlet and power, then call a Kerrville plumber.
What to expect during a professional visit
A thorough visit from Kerrville plumbers follows a logical path. The tech will ask about age, symptoms, and recent changes in the home. They will verify power or gas supply, check for error codes, and test components with a meter rather than guessing. For gas units, they will clean the burner, check the thermocouple or flame sensor, and test draft. For electric units, they will test elements and thermostats and inspect wiring for heat damage at the terminals.

Many calls wrap in under an hour if the issue is a thermostat, element, igniter, or minor leak at the drain valve. If the tank needs replacement, a same-day swap is common. In garages with tight clearances or older venting, the team will bring the correct vent adapters, new dielectric nipples, a pan, and a code-compliant expansion tank if needed. Expect a clear price upfront and a quick review of options that match the home’s usage.
Code, safety, and permits in Kerrville
Local code requires a working temperature and pressure relief valve piped to a safe discharge point. Gas units must have proper venting with correct rise, clearances, and secure joints. In many older installs, the pan drain is missing or dead-ended. A new installation should include a pan with a line to daylight or a drain. Water heaters installed in garages need proper elevation above the floor for ignition source clearance unless sealed-combustion. In homes with high static pressure, a listed expansion tank protects the system and keeps the relief valve from lifting.

Permits matter. A licensed plumber in Kerrville pulls permits for replacements when required. This protects homeowners and helps insurance claims later. It also ensures combustion air, venting, seismic strapping where applicable, and gas sizing meet standards.
How to extend water heater life in Kerrville homes
Small habits add years. Keep the thermostat at 120 degrees for daily use, then use a mixing valve if higher storage temperature is needed for sanitation. Test the T&P valve yearly with a quick lift and reseat. If it continues to drip afterward, have it replaced. Flush a few gallons from the drain twice a year to check for sand or heavy sediment. If it runs sandy, consider a prefilter. Check anode rods every two to three years. In homes with a water softener, rods deplete faster. Replace before they disappear completely.

Watch household pressure. A simple gauge on a hose bib tells the story. Ideal pressure sits near 55 to 65 psi. If the gauge shows 80 psi or higher, talk with a plumber near me about a pressure-reducing valve. High pressure stresses water heaters, toilets, and supply lines.
Real-world Kerrville examples
In Riverhill, a family called about hot water fading mid-shower. The tank was 11 years old and rumbled loudly when heating. The plumber flushed the tank, but the sediment had compacted. The recommendation was a 50-gallon high-recovery gas replacement with an expansion tank. The new unit cut morning recovery time, and the rumble disappeared.

A homeowner near Starkey Elementary had an electric water heater that tripped the high-limit button twice in a week. The tech found a lower element shorted to ground due to scale buildup. After replacing both elements and thermostats and flushing sediment, the unit returned to stable operation. The homeowner added a quick annual flush to the fall maintenance list.

In a Comanche Trace home, cloudy, odorous hot water showed up after prolonged travel. Testing pointed to a magnesium anode reaction. Swapping to an aluminum-zinc anode and sanitizing the tank cleared the odor. A mixing valve allowed higher storage temperature to help prevent future odor without scald risk.
Repair or replace: a practical rule
A simple rule guides many decisions. If the tank is under 8 years old and not leaking, repair often makes sense. If it is over 10 years and needs a burner assembly, gas valve, or multiple electric components, the cost of parts and labor can approach half the price of a new unit. Factor in efficiency, warranty, and the inconvenience of another failure. Many homeowners choose replacement at that point.

For budget planning, standard tanks come with 6, 9, or 12-year warranties. The tank itself is often the same across options, but the longer warranty usually includes better parts coverage and sometimes a larger anode. A Kerrville plumber can explain the differences plainly so the homeowner can decide where to invest.
Choosing a local pro for fast, clean work
Hot water issues do not wait. A team that knows plumbing Kerrville TX can diagnose quickly because they see the same patterns every week. They show up with common parts on the truck that fit local models. They know which attics are too tight for a heat pump unit and which garages need combustion air solutions because they have solved those exact problems on nearby streets.

For homeowners searching Kerrville plumber services or plumbers Kerrville TX, the most valuable sign is a clear process and straight communication. Look for same-day slots, upfront pricing, and a tidy installation that meets code. Local references matter. So do small touches like pan drains that actually reach daylight and supply lines that are copper or stainless steel rather than plastic flex where code prohibits it.
Ready help from a plumber near me
Whether the water heater needs a reset, a new element, or a full replacement, fast action keeps life moving. If the unit is leaking or the pilot refuses to stay lit, skip the guesswork. A call to a trusted Kerrville plumber brings a clean fix and guidance that fits the home, budget, and daily routine. The right team will diagnose, repair when sensible, and replace when that provides better value, all while keeping the home safe and code-compliant.

For homeowners in Kerrville, TX who want reliable hot water back today, reach out to a local pro who understands the quirks of our water and our homes. Clear answers, solid parts, and respectful service turn a cold morning into a quick turnaround.

<section>

Gottfried Plumbing LLC provides residential and commercial plumbing services throughout Kerrville, TX, and nearby communities. The company handles water heater repair and replacement, leak detection, drain cleaning, and full plumbing maintenance. Licensed plumbers are available 24 hours a day for emergency calls, offering quick and dependable solutions for leaks, backups, and broken fixtures. Gottfried Plumbing focuses on quality workmanship, honest service, and reliable support for homes and businesses across the Boerne area.

<div itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/LocalBusiness">

<strong itemprop="name">Gottfried Plumbing LLC</strong>

Phone: (830) 331-2055 tel:+18303312055

Website:
https://www.gottfriedplumbing.com https://www.gottfriedplumbing.com/,
24 Hour Plumber https://sites.google.com/view/24hour-plumber,
Boerne Plumbing https://sites.google.com/view/boerneplumbing/home

Social Media:
Yelp https://www.yelp.com/biz/gottfried-plumbing-boerne,
Facebook https://www.facebook.com/p/Gottfried-Plumbing-100075979452032/

Map: View on Google Maps https://maps.app.goo.gl/Kvg3Ga6mCuVSbLfZ7

</div>
</section>